Improving the customer experience in insurance

Last updated
Nov 29, 2023
While it's common for insurance providers to primarily engage with policyholders during renewal or payment reminders, a new approach is to consistently provide value and engage with policyholders throughout the year, proactively strengthening the overall customer experience.

The power of consistent engagement

Rather than solely focusing on interacting with policyholders at renewal or when seeking payment, insurance companies can optimize their relationship-building efforts by engaging with policyholders consistently throughout the year.

Consistent engagement ensures that policyholders feel valued and supported, fostering a positive perception of the insurance company and its brand.

For example, send an email or SMS text once a month asking for feedback, and adding an incentive or commitment to donate to a charity. Companies like Amazon often askfor feedback or public reviews on select products in return for small credits like a $5 Amazon gift card.

Enhancing Value Delivery

Delivering consistent value to policyholders is an essential component of successful customer engagement. Insurance companies can go above and beyond by offering additional perks, benefits, and rewards to policyholders.

For example, T-Mobile offers a weekly program to their customers called T-Mobile Tuesdays where there is a small reward like a $2 Dunkin' Donuts gift card each week, or even once a year a free annual subscription to MLB TV.

Just like T-Mobile's T-Mobile Tuesdays program, insurance companies can create their own reward initiatives that give policyholders something to look forward to each week.

You have the flexibility of choosing how frequently you communicate with customers. Exclusive discounts, special offers from partner brands, personalized recommendations, or even access to educational resources related to insurance and risk management make great rewards.

T-Mobile offers tons of free add-ons to their bundle packages, such as their Magenta and newly offered 5G home internet:

Why incorporate perks all year round?

Increased satisfaction: Cultivate a sense of appreciation and satisfaction. When customers feel valued and receive ongoing benefits, they are more likely to view the insurance company favorably and remain loyal.

Building trust and loyalty: Demonstrate a commitment to their well-being beyond just financial transactions. This helps build trust and loyalty, encouraging policyholders to choose the insurance company as their long-term partner.

Improved retention rates: Continually deliver value and engaging with policyholders throughout the year to improve policyholder retention rates. When policyholders experience ongoing worthwhile benefits, they are more likely to stay with the insurance provider rather than seeking alternatives.

Strengthened brand perception: Insurance companies that prioritize consistent engagement and value delivery subtly differentiate themselves from their competitors.

For example, asking for authentic public reviews on sites like Trustpilot with proof, in return to discounts on ongoing policy plans that are active. Tower Appliances is a great example:

‍Implementing consistently

Launching partnerships in house can be notoriously hard. Platforms like Paylode can help you launch a perks program quickly, going from 0 to fully-fledged perks integration seamlessly. Third parties also negotiate the partnership deals, getting you access to deeper discounts than you'd be able to drum up on your own.

If you need help deciding how to first implement, let's talk.

‍

About the author
Adrienne Kmetz
Adrienne is a marketing expert with a career history of working in startups of all sizes, from early stage to series A. She has 17+ years of experience writing about business, finance, and entrepreneurship. She went to Colorado College where she majored in skiing.
Engagement insider
Weekly tips you can skim in under 1min — sent at the same time every week. Bite sized, actionable insights for perks people.
Read about our privacy policy.
You're subscribed.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Editorial promise
Our editorial team aims to write trustworthy, helpful guides for business leaders building perks programs. We fact-check every article at the time of publishing.

Keep reading

Cut Billing Costs by 50% and Speed Up Payments with Low IT Work | Go Paperless

Cut Billing Costs by 50% and Speed Up Payments with Low IT Work | Go Paperless

Let’s be honest—billing operations in 2025 still look way too much like they did in 2010. Paper bills. Credit card fees. Payment delays. High mailing costs. And endless email reminders that no one reads. Sound familiar? If you're leading billing, operations, or finance at a large insurance, utility, or telecom company, you already know how outdated and expensive these systems are. But here’s the good news: there’s a simple way to fix it—and it doesn’t involve begging your IT team for resources.
Ruoff Mortgage Partners with Paylode to Enhance Customer Engagement and Loyalty Through Perks and Incentives

Ruoff Mortgage Partners with Paylode to Enhance Customer Engagement and Loyalty Through Perks and Incentives

Ruoff Mortgage has partnered with Paylode, the leading customer engagement and loyalty platform, to enhance the Ruoff Rewards program. This collaboration provides exclusive perks and discounts to Ruoff customers, helping them save on essential homeownership services while improving engagement, lead generation, and customer retention. Through targeted incentives, Ruoff aims to drive loyalty and optimize its digital engagement strategies. The partnership will introduce double point days, special perk-based rewards, and automated engagement campaigns to enhance the homeownership experience.
Canada Post’s 2025 Rate Hike: A Billing Leader’s Guide to Cutting Costs with eBilling

Canada Post’s 2025 Rate Hike: A Billing Leader’s Guide to Cutting Costs with eBilling

Canada Post's 2025 postage rate hike has increased mailing costs by 25%, making paper billing unsustainable for businesses. This article explores the financial impact across industries—including utilities, telecom, finance, and real estate—and highlights the cost-saving benefits of eBilling. Learn how automation platforms like Paylode help billing teams incentivize digital adoption, streamline processes, and reduce late payments. Now is the time to transition to paperless billing and autopay to mitigate rising costs and improve customer satisfaction.

See how businesses use Paylode to incentivize and engage their customers

We care about your data in our privacy policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.